The Complete Guide to the Best Metal Detecting Knee Pads: Comfort and Protection in the Field

Metal detecting is a hobby that often brings us closer to the ground than we might expect. As detectorists, we spend a significant amount of time on our knees, sifting through soil, mud, and sand in search of hidden treasures. However, this close contact with the earth can be uncomfortable and potentially harmful to our knees. The ground is often cold, wet, and littered with small stones, gravel, and other debris that can make our detecting experience quite unpleasant. Moreover, we may encounter less savory elements like bacteria-laden animal droppings or even broken glass.

This is where knee pads come into play. They serve as a crucial piece of equipment for any serious detectorist, providing comfort, protection, and peace of mind as we pursue our passion. But with various types and models available, how do you choose the best metal detecting knee pads for your needs? This comprehensive guide is here to help you make an informed decision.

The Importance of Knee Pads in Metal Detecting

Before we take a closer look into the types of knee pads available, let’s consider why they’re so essential for metal detectorists:

1. Protection from Sharp Objects: Knee pads shield your knees from rocks, broken glass, and other sharp debris you might encounter in the field.
2. Comfort During Extended Sessions: They provide cushioning that allows you to kneel for longer periods without discomfort.
3. Insulation from Cold and Wet Conditions: Knee pads create a barrier between your knees and the often cold, damp ground.
4. Hygiene: They protect you from direct contact with potentially unsanitary surfaces.
5. Prevention of Long-term Knee Problems: Regular use of knee pads can help prevent chronic knee issues that might develop from frequent kneeling on hard surfaces.

Types of Metal Detecting Knee Pads

There are three main types of knee pads suitable for metal detecting, each with its own set of advantages and potential drawbacks:

1. Internal Pocket Knee Pads

Description: These are simple foam pads that fit into specially designed pockets in work trousers or detecting pants.

Pros:

• Discreet and low-profile
• Don’t interfere with movement
• Can be used with any pants that have knee pad pockets

Cons:

• Rely on correct positioning of the trouser pocket
• May need to be trimmed to fit different pocket sizes
• Offer less protection than external pads

2. Sports Style Protective Knee Pads

Description: These are compression-fit knee pads worn directly on the knee, similar to those used in sports like volleyball or basketball.

Pros:

• Always in the correct position on your knee
• Often provide both cushioning and knee support
• Generally lightweight and flexible

Cons:

• May be too tight for some users, potentially restricting movement
• Might not fit comfortably under all types of trousers
• Can be hot to wear for extended periods

3. External Hard Shell Knee Pads

Description: These are larger, more robust knee pads worn over your trousers and secured with straps.

Pros:

• Offer the highest level of protection
• Often feature gel inserts for added comfort
• Suitable for rough terrain or areas with potential hazards

Cons:

• Bulkier and more noticeable than other types
• Can be heavier and potentially less comfortable for long wear
• May interfere with movement more than other types

Top Picks for Each Type of Metal Detecting Knee Pad

Now that we’ve covered the different types, let’s look at our top picks for each category:

Best Internal Pocket Metal Detecting Knee Pad

Absolute Apparel Trouser Internal Pocket Metal Detecting Kneepad

Price: £5.59

Specifications:

• Material: Pressure-absorbing foam
• Size: One size, trimmable
• Compatibility: Fits any knee pad equipped workwear trousers

Pros:

• Lightweight and comfortable
• Can be trimmed to fit various pocket sizes
• Very affordable
• Versatile – can be used with any trousers that have knee pad pockets

Cons:

• Relies on correct positioning of trouser pockets
• Offers less protection than external pads
• May need replacement more frequently than harder-wearing options

The Absolute Apparel Internal Pocket Knee Pad is an excellent choice for detectorists who prefer a discreet, lightweight option. These pads are made from pressure-absorbing foam that provides a good balance of comfort and protection. Their versatility is a significant advantage – they can be trimmed to fit any trousers equipped with knee pad pockets, making them a flexible option for various detecting outfits.

At £5.59, these pads offer exceptional value for money. They’re an ideal choice for beginners or those who detect in relatively forgiving terrain. However, for those frequently kneeling on very rough or hazardous surfaces, a more robust option might be preferable.

Best Sports Style Compression Fit Metal Detecting Knee Pad

RDX Foam Metal Detecting Support Knee Pad

Price: £16.99

Specifications:

• Material: 100% polyester elasticated exterior, EVA and foam padded cushion
• Certifications: CE certified, SATRA approved, OEKO-TEX 100 certified
• Features: Moisture-wicking QD1 lining, 4-way segmented safety design, Quick-EZ hook-and-loop closure
• Sold as a pair
• Available in various colors and sizes

Pros:

• High-quality construction with multiple certifications
• Provides both cushioning and knee support
• Moisture-wicking lining for comfort during extended use
• Adjustable for a perfect fit
• Versatile – suitable for various activities beyond metal detecting

Cons:

• May be too warm for use in hot weather
• Might not fit comfortably under all types of trousers
• More expensive than basic internal pocket pads

The RDX Foam Support Knee Pad offers a great balance of protection, support, and comfort. These pads are designed to stay in place on your knee, ensuring consistent protection as you move around your detecting site. The EVA padded cushion absorbs shocks and distributes weight evenly, reducing stress on your knees during long detecting sessions.

One standout feature is the moisture-wicking QD1 lining, which helps keep you comfortable even when you work up a sweat. The Quick-EZ hook-and-loop closure allows for easy adjustment, ensuring a snug fit for various leg sizes.

While these pads are pricier than basic options, their durability and versatility make them a good investment for regular detectorists. They’re particularly well-suited for those who detect in varied terrain or who need additional knee support.

Best External Hard Shell Metal Detecting Knee Pad

Viper Hard Shell Metal Detecting Knee Pads

Price: £15.95

Specifications:

• Material: Hard X-Shell plates on front, closed cell foam inner padding
• Features: Quick release buckles, elasticated straps with hook and loop adjustment, inner anti-slip patch
• Sold as a pair

Pros:

• Offers maximum protection with hard shell exterior
• Adjustable straps for a secure fit
• Quick release buckles for easy on and off
• Anti-slip patch to keep pads in place
• Suitable for rough terrain and hazardous areas

Cons:

• Bulkier than other options
• May interfere with movement more than lighter pads
• Could be too warm for use in hot weather

The Viper Hard Shell Knee Pads are the top choice for detectorists who prioritize protection or frequently work in challenging terrain. The hard X-Shell plates on the front provide robust protection against rocks, thorns, and other hazards you might encounter in the field.

Despite their tough exterior, these pads don’t skimp on comfort. The closed cell foam inner padding cushions your knees, while the anti-slip patch helps keep the pads in place as you move. The quick release buckles and adjustable straps make these pads easy to put on and take off, even when wearing gloves.

While they’re more noticeable than other types of knee pads, the level of protection they offer makes them worth considering, especially if you often detect in areas with rough or potentially dangerous ground conditions.

How to Choose the Right Metal Detecting Knee Pads

When selecting knee pads for metal detecting, consider the following factors:

1. Terrain: If you primarily detect on soft ground like beaches, lighter pads may suffice. For rocky or hazardous areas, opt for more robust protection.
2. Climate: In hot weather, breathable pads are crucial. For cold or wet conditions, waterproof options are beneficial.
3. Comfort: Ensure the pads don’t restrict your movement or cause discomfort during long detecting sessions.
4. Durability: Consider how often you’ll be using the pads and choose a pair that will withstand your level of use.
5. Ease of Use: Look for pads that are easy to put on and take off, especially if you’ll be wearing them intermittently.
6. Compatibility: If you have specific detecting trousers, ensure the pads you choose are compatible.

Care and Maintenance of Your Knee Pads

To ensure your knee pads last and continue to provide optimal protection:

1. Clean them regularly, following the manufacturer’s instructions.
2. Allow them to dry completely before storage to prevent mold and odors.
3. Check straps and closures regularly for wear and tear.
4. Replace pads when they show signs of significant wear or damage.

Conclusion

Investing in a good pair of knee pads can significantly enhance your metal detecting experience, providing comfort and protection that allows you to focus on the thrill of the hunt. Whether you opt for the discreet Absolute Apparel Internal Pocket Pads, the supportive RDX Foam Pads, or the heavy-duty Viper Hard Shell Pads, the right knee protection can make a world of difference in your detecting adventures.

Remember, the best knee pads for you will depend on your specific detecting style, preferred terrain, and personal comfort preferences. Don’t be afraid to try different types to find what works best for you.